CommonPicks

How we pick

The short version: the Overall Pick is the offer we would buy ourselves — lowest honest total cost for the condition, from a seller we trust, with returns if it goes wrong. Affiliate commission can only break a genuine tie, never create one.

Hard filters — an offer cannot be the Pick if:

· Seller rating is below 98% or the seller has too little history to judge
· Shipping cost is unknown, so the total price would be a guess
· The price is stale for its source type (live API vs daily feed limits)
· Returns are absent or the item is sold as-is without that being unmistakably labelled
· The condition label can't be verified against the source's own grade
· It is a parts-only listing — parts are hidden from results by default and can never be the Pick (you can reveal them with the “Include parts-only” filter)

Scoring (0–100)

FactorWeightWhat it measures
Total price incl. shipping45Cheapest eligible offer scores full points; others scale against the median
Condition value25Condition-adjusted value — certified refurbished well below new price can beat new
Seller trust20Rating, volume, and source type (retailer direct > top-rated marketplace seller > individual)
Returns & protection10Free returns, return window length, platform money-back guarantee

The affiliate tie-break

Only when two offers finish within 3 points of each other AND within 2% on total price may the offer that earns CommonPicks a commission become the Pick. The Pick always shows its reasons, and this rule is disclosed right on the Pick. Trust is the product — a Pick we can't defend is worth more lost than won.

Freshness

Live-API prices are labelled "checked just now". Feed prices carry their date and time. If a price can't be refreshed, we hide it rather than show a stale one.